← Back to ranking
The Godfather· little-italy
#2

Mona Lisa

The Godfather · little italy · $$

The bread is the boss. Mortadella, capicola, prosciutto cotto, provolone, and the oil-and-vinegar that's been training San Diegans since before either of us had teeth.

The score

Bread
9.8
Filling
9.7
Vibe
9.5

Final score9.7/10

GOAT

The basics

2061 India St

Open · closes 8pm


Pairs with

A Peroni in a foil-wrapped hand


#classic#sub#cured-meat#cash-friendly

There's a slice of India Street where, on a good day, the sidewalk smells like a sandwich shop. That's the block.

The bread is the boss.

The bread

This is where my cousin loses his mind. The roll has a crust that scares your dentist and a crumb soft enough to forgive everything else. He'll defend this bread like family. I'll be honest — the bread alone is why this place was #1 for three years. Buon Cibo finally outpaced it by a hair, and the only reason it did is the salumi program. The bread here is still the best in the city. We'll fight anybody who says otherwise.

The filling

Mortadella, capicola, prosciutto cotto, provolone. Pepperoncini if you ask. Oil-and-vinegar that I'm pretty sure they make in the basement out of pure Italian-American instinct. It's not a trick filling. It's the canon, executed by people who've done it ten thousand times.

My cousin will tell you the prosciutto cotto used to be sliced thicker. I tell him he's getting old.

The people

Three generations of one family. A register that still hand-writes the receipts. A counter where the line moves because everybody knows what they want. The kid working the slicer is somebody's grandson — probably yours, eventually.

The verdict

For half of San Diego, this is the sandwich. The one you think about at 11pm on a Tuesday. It dropped a slot only because somebody finally built a more interesting Italian deli across town. It didn't get worse. The bar moved.